I am just about as non confrontational as they come. In ninety-nine percent of situations, I
actively try to avoid conflict. I simply
do not see a purpose to run in to a conflict when there is any way to avoid
it. I am a happy person who tries to be
around people who are happy so I just do not like being around anger. With that being said, I have been in my fair
share of conflicts.
I worked at a country club for 4 years as a lifeguard. After my third year as a guard, our manager
announced that he was going to quit and nominate a successor. There were really only two candidates for the
position. It was one of my good friends
at the club, code named Beth, and myself.
I ended up getting the position because of my great relationship with my
boss. My boss and I really had become
very close.
At first, there did not seem to be any sort of conflict at
all. For the first few weeks of the
summer, there was never any problem in terms of scheduling or problems at the
club. Then a problem arose. There was a concert on a Friday afternoon
that a ton of our employees wanted to go to.
I had already decided that I was going to work the event. A little background about our policies. We do not schedule shifts based on
seniority. Unless previously notified, I
was in charge of choosing who works when.
Since this event was one of the biggest events of the year
for the club, I scheduled our most experienced employees. There were five of us working that day and everything
seemed to be going just fine. The event
ended and Beth came up to me and told me that due to the decisions I had made
that she was going to quit. At first I was
taken back. At the moment I could not
realize that I had made any terrible decisions that could lead to a person
quitting, especially one of my friends.
Instead of arguing with Beth at the time, I asked her if we could meet
the next day so we both had some time to think it over and she agreed.
Over the next 24 hours I thought about a lot of things. I took this very personally as I was in
charge of the operations of the pool and Beth is one of my friends. I tried to look at the conflict through Beth’s
eyes. She was upset that she could not
go to this concert. In my opinion that
was no reason to quit.
The next day we met and we both had a chance to say our
piece. I told her that I was sorry for putting
her on that day, but she was very understanding of what I had to do. I tried to put her into my shoes and let her
see the situation that was presented to me.
She ended up talking to me about how she realized that she may have
overreacted a little. She clearly had
thought about the conflict a lot as well.
She told me that her biggest problem with the situation was that we had
been working together for 3 full years together and that she had no say in the
situation. That was the first time that
she had shown any animosity towards me about being elected pool manager over
her.
Clearly the source of this problem was that I was given
hierarchy over Beth. Once everything
cleared up, we both new that we had both made some minor errors in the
situation and that we both would like to redo some actions we took. This was a huge learning experience for
me. I really learned a lot about
conflict resolution and leadership.
My favorite part of the situation was that it was handled
between Beth and I. We were the most
mature and had been there the longest and it was imperative that we handled it
just between us. I feel as though the
conflict could not have been avoided because even if it did not happen right
then, there were emotions building up towards what happened. Overall, I am happy with how the situation
ended as Beth stayed at the pool and that helped me grow as a person.
This is a pretty good story but let me ask, do you think of Beth as a laid back person like yourself? If so, might there have been other smaller things that bothered her when you became the manager, decisions that you made that she would have made differently? It seems to me that little grudges turn into bigger ones, but one doesn't typically blow a cork the first time around.
ReplyDeleteIndeed, if there were other things that were bothering Beth about the job before the event you describe, then the situation is better termed a conflict. Everyone has disagreements from time to time. Not all disagreements result in conflict. Those disagreements that can be be resolved amicably do not. It's when the disagreements don't resolve and instead fester that conflicts emerge.
So I wonder if in this case you might have anticipated Beth's reaction ahead of time and done something in advance to prevent it from happening in the first place. I will note with this that you probably couldn't do that immediately after you were selected manager, because while disappointed that she wasn't selected, she likely would have put on a brave face then and said everything is fine. It would have needed to be some time after that but before the event you describe. Good management diffuses potential issues before they arise and in that sense is proactive. Was there an opportunity to be proactive here?
Beth is definitely not as laid back as I am as a person. There for sure were little things that I did that bothered her. Hard to remember all of the little things as it was a few years ago.
ReplyDeleteA lot of little disagreements in turn become conflicts. I know I have little things that bother me that always can turn into bigger problems.
I agree with what you said about diffusing problems before they become problems. That is why this experience was such a great learning experience for me as I learned so many ways to be a leader. I also learned a lot of mistakes that I made and ways not to be a leader.